pony death and inaction at equine sanctuary leads to investigation and 62 animal cruelty charges against Sarah Rabinowitz. She owns Labrador Hill Equine Sanctuary in NJ What connection does this dead pony have to the animal cruelty charges filed against Sarah Rabinowitz at Labrador Hill Equine Sanctuary?

Pony Death Prompts Animal Cruelty Charges at Horse ‘Sanctuary’

Dead Pony

The owner of Labrador Hill Equine Sanctuary in Waterford, N.J. faces more than 60 counts of animal cruelty and neglect.

A pony’s death precipitated events that landed Sarah Rabinowitz (Mognoni), 62, in trouble with the law. That’s because Rabinowitz allegedly failed to acknowledge or make changes to help her non-profit’s horses.

Veterinarians euthanized at least two horses on site since last Tuesday, due to the animals’ poor prognoses.

Rabinowitz touts the farm’s “natural setting” with an “eco-friendly approach to property and facilities.”

Although, the barren acreage, overcrowded with horses is seen differently by some. That’s because horses stand riddled with flies stomping the dirt without reprieve as their tails work overtime.

An aerial photo of the herd at Labrador Equine Sanctuary in New Jersey
The horse’s body is designed for eating grass and other vegetation. They graze then move in the wild.

Authorities executed a search warrant at Labrador Hill Equine Sanctuary, which is operated by Rabinowitz, just over a week ago. As a result of the search, a court order requires that she immediately fix “insufficient water sources and inadequate shelter” on the property.

Court documents obtained by Horse Authority state approximately 75 animals were on the property including horses, ponies, mules, donkeys, and two goats.

Horse health hazards

Investigators documented various hazards during the search, including:

  • – “inadequate water or no water
  • – “inadequate shelter”
  • – 28 of 29 horses examined by the NJ Department of Agriculture were dehydrated,
  • – additionally, the 29 horses had both inadequate water and shelter,
  • – pony with a “severe leg injury”,
  • – two horses with eye injuries,
  • – toxic plants, including jimsonweed, pigweed, and morning weed,
  • – “numerous” hay bales in the main pasture had netting around them (if horses eat netting, it is deadly),
  • – flashing exposed on outside of a barn,
  • – boards laying on the ground with exposed nails,
  • – along with exposed nails and broken fence rails.


Camden County prosecutors charged Rabinowitz with 57 counts of fourth-degree causing bodily injury to an animal. She also faces five counts of animal cruelty. The complaint states Rabinowitz “knowingly or recklessly caused bodily injury to a living animal or creature by failing to provide the living animal or creature with [the] necessary care…”

Rabinowitz was arrested and released pending court on Tuesday, July 24th.

Additionally, Superior Court Judge John T. Kelley signed an order allowing horse owners to remove their animals from Labrador Hill.

Those interested in doing so must first contact Investigator Timothy Lyons of the Waterford Township Police with proof of ownership, which is a Bill of Sale.

JR before brought to NJ equine sanctuary owner accused of animal cruelty Sarah Rabinowitz
JR before going to Labrador Hill Equine Sanctuary run by Sarah Rabinowitz.
JR leaves Labrador Hill Equine Sanctuary emaciated
JR leaves Labrador Hill Equine Sanctuary in an emaciated state despite arriving in good flesh.

Horse rescues placed horses here, too

After a heatwave in late June, Weekstown resident Ellen Strack tells us she received a photo of a pony’s body in a paddock with its herd at Labrador Hill Equine Sanctuary. Rigor mortis had already set in. The carcass allegedly remained there for a day.

Strack says Rabinowitz was always personable on social media although she doesn’t know her. Strack operates South Jersey Horse Rescue, which, “sent two truckloads of hay [to Labrador Hill] about 2 years ago.” It was winter and Strack was helping another rescue locally.

After receiving the dead pony photo, Strack says she offered Rabinowitz help. Strack’s offer got her an invitation to the farm although Rabinowitz wanted a different type of assistance. “She wanted me to testify for her as zoning issues were taking her to court [sic].”

A horse allegedly neglected by Sarah Rabinowitz.
One of the horses allegedly neglected by Sarah Rabinowitz.

To illustrate, more than two times the number of horses authorized live on what Strack describes as “15 filthy acres.”

On July 9th, Strack and two volunteers offered Rabinowitz help again. They drove over with four bags of horse feed and chopped timothy hay.

Strack says what she witnessed on the farm, including a lack of basic horse husbandry, is concerning. She cleaned horses’ wounds although Rabinowitz wouldn’t allow her to spray the horses with fly repellant.

“She [Rabinowitz] said they [the horses] don’t get dinner and hay is enough for horses to survive,” Strack says. Additionally, she says Rabinowitz blamed the horses’ conditions on old age. “She [Rabinowitz] told me the donkeys were at fault for contracting EPM [equine protozoal myeloencephalitis]…” and that “many horses died there probably from EPM or Lymes”.

Two days later Strack contacted authorities after she says her final plea went unanswered.

“I tried to be kind and understanding to Sarah, but she insisted the horses were fine… and she needed no help.”

It is unclear if Rabinowitz has a veterinarian for routine health care. The non-profit’s 2016 tax records show it spent $3,875 on veterinary care for a reported 52 horses. The organization spent almost as much on landscaping — $2,377.

Sarah Rabinowitz responds

Rabinowitz responded to our message with questions regarding the non-profit. The defendant asserts she is the victim of, “death threats, a wholly false and subversive personal and professional character attack [sic],” on social media and in the press.

Rabinowitz also blames, “a level of hate from Ms. Strack and her followers that must appear suspicious to intelligent observers.”

The art teacher turned self-proclaimed horse expert and horsemanship riding instructor asserts her commitment to an “aggressive defense in court and the safety of the animals”.

Strack and others in the horse community are asking prosecutors to prohibit Rabinowitz from future horse ownership if she is found guilty or takes a deal.

“What is most disturbing to me is her complete lack of awareness … and her ignoring the obvious suffering of the animals,” Strack adds.

Stay with us for more on this developing story.